The Factories of Lost Children
By
KATHARINE WEBER
Published:
March 25, 2006
Bethany,
Conn.
Enlarge
This Image
George
Bates
NINETY-FIVE
years ago, March 25 also fell on a Saturday. At 4:40 p.m. on that sunny
afternoon in 1911, only minutes before the end of the workday, a fire broke out
on the eighth floor of the Asch Building, a block east of Washington Square in
Manhattan.
The
Triangle Waist Company occupied the top three floors of the 10-story building.
There, some 600 workers were employed in the manufacture of ladies'
shirtwaists, most of them teenage girls who spoke little English and were fresh
off the boat from Russia, the Austro-Hungarian Empire and Italy. The fire,
probably caused by a carelessly tossed match or cigarette butt (there were perhaps
100 men working at the Triangle), engulfed the premises in minutes.
The
factory owners and the office staff on the 10th floor, all but one, escaped
onto the roof and climbed to an adjacent building on Waverly Place. But on the
eighth and ninth floors, the workers were trapped by a deadly combination of
highly combustible materials, workrooms crowded by dense rows of table-mounted
sewing machines, doors that were locked or opened inward, inadequate fire
escapes, and the lack of any plan or instruction.
Before
the first horse-drawn fire engines arrived at the scene, girls — some holding
hands, in twos and threes — had already begun to jump from the windows. The
hundred-foot drop to the cobbled street was not survivable. The firemen
deployed their nets, but the force of gravity drove the bodies of the girls
straight through to the pavement, and they died on impact.
The
ladders on the fire trucks were raised quickly, but the New York City Fire
Department of 1911 was not equipped to combat fires above six stories — the
limit of those ladders. The top floors of the Asch Building, a neo-Renaissance
"fireproof" warehouse completed in 1901 in full compliance with
building codes, burned relentlessly.
The
workers trapped near the windows on the eighth and ninth floors made the fast
and probably instinctive choice to jump instead of burning or suffocating in
the smoke. The corpses of the jumpers, by some estimates as many as 70, could
at least be identified. But the bodies of most of those who died inside the Triangle
Waist Company — trapped by the machinery, piled up on the wrong side of doors,
heaped in the stairwells and elevator shafts — were hideously charred, many
beyond recognition.
Before
15 minutes had elapsed, some 140 workers had burned, fallen from the collapsing
fire escapes, or jumped to their deaths. Several more, critically injured, died
in the days that followed, putting the official death toll at 146.
But
what happened to the children who were working at the Triangle Waist Company
that afternoon?
By
most contemporary accounts, it was common knowledge that children were usually
on the premises. They were hidden from the occasional inspectors, but underage
girls, as young as 9 or 10, worked in most New York garment factories, sewing
buttons and trimming threads. Where were they on this particular Saturday
afternoon?
There
are no descriptions of children surviving the fire. Various lists of those who
died 95 years ago today — 140 named victims plus six who were never identified
(were some of those charred remains children?) — include one 11-year-old, two
14-year-olds, three 15-year-olds, 16 16- year-olds, and 14 17-year-olds. Were
the ages of workers, living and dead, modified to finesse the habitual
violation of child labor laws in 1911? How many children actually died that
day? We will never know. And now 1911 is almost beyond living memory.
But
we will also never know how many children were among the dead on May 10, 1993,
in Thailand when the factory of the Kader Industrial Toy Company (a supplier to
Hasbro and Fisher-Price) went up in flames. Most of the 188 workers who died
were described as teenage girls.
We
will never know with any certainty how many children died on Nov. 25, 2000, in
a fire at the Chowdhury Knitwear and Garment factory near Dhaka, Bangladesh
(most of the garments made in Bangladesh are contracted by American retailers,
including Wal-Mart and the Gap), where at least 10 of the 52 trapped in the
flames by locked doors and windows were 10 to 14 years old.
And
we will never know how many children died just last month, on Feb. 23, in the
KTS Composite Textile factory fire in Chittagong, Bangladesh. The official
death toll has climbed into the 50's, but other sources report that at least 84
workers lost their lives. It's a familiar story: crowded and unsafe conditions,
locked exits, hundreds of undocumented female workers as young as 12, a deadly
fire. There may never be another tragic factory fire in America that takes the
lives of children. We don't lock them into sweatshops any more. There are child
labor laws, fire codes.
But
as long as we don't question the source of the inexpensive clothing we wear, as
long as we don't wonder about the children in those third world factories who
make the inexpensive toys we buy for our own children, those fires will occur
and young girls and boys will continue to die. They won't die because of
natural catastrophes like monsoons and earthquakes; they will die because it
has become our national habit to outsource, and these days we outsource our
tragedies, too.
Katharine
Weber is the author of the forthcoming novel "Triangle."
No comments:
Post a Comment